Joseph Gerard Cancellare was arrested after authorities accused him of mailing a greeting card covered in peanut butter to a woman he knew had a severe, life-threatening allergy. The 68-year-old man faces charges of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence after investigators determined he intentionally sought to harm the victim.
As reported by CBS News, the victim discovered the blue envelope in her driveway after returning home from work. She noted that the envelope felt greasy and displayed unfamiliar handwriting. Upon opening the card, she found a brown substance smeared across the inside, which she quickly identified as peanut butter.
She immediately dropped the item and washed her hands, but she still developed hives on both arms and a tingling sensation that reportedly persisted for six hours. She told police that even minor contact or airborne particles could trigger a reaction that restricts her breathing, creating a situation where she could die without urgent medical help.
He sent the envelope from a different city
Investigators pieced this case together by looking at the two stamps on the envelope. They worked with a U.S. postal inspector to trace the 15-digit code printed on the stamps back to a self-service kiosk at a Davie post office on South University Drive. The stamps were bought on August 8, 2025, with a Visa card.
Because the kiosk captured a photo of the person making the purchase, police had a clear image to work with. Records confirmed the Visa card belonged to Cancellare. When police showed the photo to the victim, she identified him right away. Other acquaintances, including someone who played in a band with him, also identified the man in the photo as Cancellare.
The history between these two people spans more than 20 years. They reportedly spent time together in social settings with their spouses, meaning Cancellare had seen the victim take precautions with her food many times. Witnesses confirmed that he understood the deadly nature of her condition.
Police believe the motive stemmed from a difficult divorce involving Cancellare and his wife, with the victim being a longtime acquaintance who found herself caught in the middle. Investigators noted that Cancellare had made comments to friends about wanting to hurt people connected to his personal situation.
To carry out this plan, police said Cancellare went to a post office in a different city than where he lived. He allegedly wore sunglasses inside the building to hide his face and used a fake name and return address on the envelope. Detectives concluded that he purposely mailed the card with the intent to cause serious bodily injury or death.
After a long investigation that included gathering medical records from 2017 to prove the severity of the allergy, police finally took Cancellare into custody at his home. He was sent to a local hospital for clearance before being moved to the Broward Sheriff’s Office main jail.
Published: Nov 17, 2026 11:45 am