A seller says USPS disposed of their shipped PlayStation 5 after calling the console perishable, leaving them out about $500. The details come from a Reddit post originally found by The Nerd Stash in r/usps_complaints by user floatinggrapes. The seller explained that they sent the console from Nevada to a Facebook Marketplace buyer, and tracking later showed the item reaching Olathe before the disposal scan.
According to the tracking information included in the post, the package arrived at the USPS facility in Olathe, KS 66061 on November 6, 2026. The next day, at 8:24 PM, the status changed to “Disposed of by Post Office.” The update stated, “Your item could not be delivered or returned to sender. Because the item was perishable, it has been disposed of by the Post Office.”
The seller clarified in an update that they were the one who sold the console, not the buyer. They wrote that the buyer was refunded after the package failed to arrive, leaving the seller out with both the PlayStation 5 and roughly $500. They added that the money had been set aside so the family could fly home for the holiday season.
Seller describes packing the console at a post office and next steps taken
The seller stated that they used a USPS box purchased at the post office itself. They said they packed the PlayStation 5 inside the facility and in front of employees. The seller noted that only the gaming console was shipped, with no controllers or other accessories included, and that there were no loose batteries.
They explained that they had shipped packages many times before without issues and did not purchase additional insurance. As a result, they said USPS directed them toward a Missing Mail request that would limit compensation to about $100. The seller wrote that they did not realize insurance needed to be considered so seriously for this type of item. Marketplace sales can get messy in other ways too, such as when one buyer flipped a $50 table for $480, and the original seller asked for more money.
In the update, the seller said they contacted the USPS Office of Inspector General and were told they should receive an update within three business days. They added that they planned to contact the Kansas office and file a police report. The seller expressed hope that CCTV footage from the facility, along with the Facebook Marketplace listing and payment records, could help show what was actually shipped.
The seller addressed several points raised by readers, including why they packed the item in front of postal workers and why the loss mattered. They wrote that the $500 was not extra spending money and that the situation left them without both the funds and the console. They also said they could not currently afford legal action after already losing the money.
Many commenters on the post suggested the “perishable” designation appeared inconsistent with an electronic console. One commenter wrote, “The fact they scanned it perishable is a dead giveaway that someone stole it.”
Another stated, “Someone 100% stole it.” A separate commenter advised filing a USPS OIG Mail Theft Report and contacting the local postmaster in Olathe directly, noting that scans are tied to specific employees.
One commenter who identified as a USPS worker wrote, “I have never scanned something as disposed. You can go up the chain and find the person who scanned that and demand answers.” Another commenter described past experiences with packages that arrived damaged or empty and said postal employees “absolutely steal and it happens with regularity.” The seller replied to one such comment by stating they had not insured the package and planned to call USPS again.
Published: Nov 17, 2026 10:30 am