A Greensboro, North Carolina, restaurant is standing by its policy of charging repeat poor tippers a 20% auto-gratuity. A photo of the rule set off a wave of anger online this week. Freeman’s Grub & Pub adds the charge once staff have seen two separate cases of a customer not tipping well without explaining why, as reported by the New York Post.
The policy first spread after a Reddit user posted a photo of the sign, saying a family member had brought them to the pub. The sign says receipts are saved and customers can question the charge. Anyone unhappy with the service can leave a name and number so staff can fix it. It also tells diners that 20% or more is the customary tip for restaurant service in the U.S.
Co-owners Kevin and Emily Purcell told the outlet that the auto-gratuity policy has been in place for five months. In that time, they’ve added 10 regular customers to the list, and they said none of them has complained. The couple said a tip under 10% for a sit-down meal is what gets a name added to the auto-gratuity list.
Kevin Purcell says the pub is facing a review bomb from people who never ate there
After the Reddit post took off, Kevin Purcell posted a video on the restaurant’s social media accounts responding to the backlash. He said Freeman’s was hit with a review bomb, with people who had never visited flooding Google and Yelp with one-star ratings. He argued that diners should know the basic expectations of tipping at a bar or restaurant by now, and that the pub’s staff is “beyond competent.”
Purcell also said tips help servers feed their kids and take care of their families, and he called customers who leave little or nothing “miserable and entitled.” He said the pub stands behind the policy and its staff “100%.” The restaurant then shared a follow-up post on Instagram, thanking regulars for leaving new reviews and supporting the servers.
Emily Purcell said the policy is about education rather than punishment, and the couple said tipping fatigue is real as more kiosks now ask for a gratuity. “Part of the reason for this policy was to educate people,” Kevin Purcell said, describing a social contract that kicks in when someone sits down and gets served. Emily added that the people attacking the pub online aren’t customers the staff wants anyway.
The rule also changes how that money is treated. The IRS considers an automatic gratuity a service charge rather than a tip, as the customer doesn’t decide the amount. That means the charge is generally handled as regular wages when it’s paid out to staff, unlike a voluntary tip that a diner chooses to leave.
Under the pub’s threshold, even the kind of tip that led a server to call out a 14% tipper in Chicago wouldn’t land a customer on the list. However, a sit-down diner who leaves less than 10% twice would see the extra 20% added to the next bill.
Reactions online were split. Critics on Reddit said they would never visit, and some suggested disputing the charge with their card company, while others said they hoped the pub would go out of business. On the restaurant’s own posts, however, regulars defended the servers, left five-star reviews and said people who won’t tip should stick to eating at home.
The pub has been a Greensboro favorite for years, landing on Yelp’s list of the top 100 places to eat in 2023, and the owners say they’ll keep the auto-gratuity list in place.
Published: Nov 19, 2026 11:00 am